This photo, taken by Ducky Tse, was first exhibited at the ‘Do you read me?’ photo exhibition.
According to the 2016 report on poverty among ethnic minorities in Hong Kong, the poverty rate among South Asian children (29.1 per cent) is significantly higher than that of all children in Hong Kong (i.e. 15.3 per cent). With the former more than double than that of the latter, it is clear that a considerable number of ethnic minorities live in poverty.
Since many South Asian children have a limited grasp of Chinese, their career options as adults are often limited to ‘3D’ jobs, i.e. dirty, dangerous and demeaning jobs; these are often low-paying jobs too. As such, this fuels intergenerational poverty.
One of the most direct ways of enabling these children to escape poverty is by providing them the support necessary to become proficient in Chinese. Oxfam Hong Kong has thus been conducting research on how to better support non-Chinese speaking students’ Chinese learning as well as on government policies in this area, and are undertaking public education initiatives to make the needs of ethnic minorities more visible.
The Four Poverties in Hong Kong
hOW WE'RE HELPING
Start from the Beginning – Chinese Supporting Scheme for Non-Chinese Speaking Students in Kindergarten (2020 – 2023)
Befriending the Chinese Language
Since 2015, Oxfam Hong Kong, the University of Hong Kong and the Education University of Hong Kong launched the ‘Start from the Beginning – Chinese Supporting Scheme for Non-Chinese Speaking Students in Kindergarten’ project. The project has entered into its 6th year and cover 96 kindergartens. It is also the first Pay-for-Success1 project in Hong Kong with cross-sector collaboration. The programme has been further enhanced to provide professional training to teachers and parental support on kindergarten primary transition, the new elements are:
• Enrichment curriculum: provide interactive enrichment classes for non-Chinese speaking children (build on the basis of learning Chinese as a second language which suits the need of NCS students).
• Learning and teaching packages: develop a new set of teaching materials composed of original pictured stories, nursery rhymes, worksheet exercises and teaching realia (such as word cards, picture cards, learning tools and toys, etc).
• Dynamic Enrichment Learning Mode (DELM): provide additional individual/group activity to NCS students during school hours. NCS students will learn Chinese in a systemic way through stories, songs and games.
• Teacher professional development: Apply train-the-trainer mode to equip teachers with teaching Chinese as a second language knowledge and strategies. We will also provide inter-school exchange opportunities and on the job training for teachers.
• Online learning community platform: an online learning platform will be built for resources sharing. A community will be formed through workshops, co-teaching, classroom observation and knowledge dissemination.
• Parent support: Organise a series of parents’ talk on primary one transition, station at kindergarten to help parents to fill primary one admission form, prepare videos on primary one admission and an overview of support to NCS students of primary schools (by district).
1Pay-for-Success also known as Social Impact Bond (SIB). It is a public-private partnership which funds effective social services through performance-base contractual arrangements and enables governments to partner with high-performing service providers by using private investments to develop, coordinate or expand effective programmes. It leverages on investors’ risk-sharing to enable funding of more innovative or preventive interventions which are currently not yet covered in the government budget.
Overcoming the Language Barrier
‘To live in Hong Kong, we must learn Chinese,’
The mother of two participants of our porject 'Start from the Beginning' , she is happy that her children study at one of the kindergartens implementing the pilot scheme.
Currently, there are about 451,000 people of non-Chinese descent living in Hong Kong. Without any support in Chinese language learning, however, many ethnic minority children find it difficult to pick up the language. Their lack of proficiency in Chinese often limits their job choices and contributes to the higher-than-average poverty rate among the ethnic minority population.
Oxfam has been working with the University of Hong Kong and the Education University of Hong Kong to implement the ‘Start from the Beginning – Chinese Supporting Scheme for Non-Chinese speaking Students in Kindergarten’ from 2015. Through pictures, stories, songs, experiential learning, group and individual learning, we aim to demonstrate effective ways of teaching ethnic minority children Chinese.
‘To live in Hong Kong, we must learn Chinese,’ said Khan Usra, a Pakistani mum of two who study at one of the kindergartens implementing the pilot scheme.
With her family set to stay here for the long haul, she sent her kids to a Chinese kindergarten so they could start learning the local language from a young age. ‘Lo see (the teacher) says my children are picking up Chinese very well [through this programme],’ she said.
Since the pilot scheme began two years ago, teachers and parents have seen much improvement; some kindergarteners even scored top marks in their Chinese exam.
With the success of this scheme, we’ve also been urging the Education Bureau to establish a Chinese as a second language curriculum, and provide sufficient resources and support to kindergartens that admit non-Chinese speaking students. We also encourage these kindergartens to ensure teachers are adequately trained.
'I want to find a job that has good opportunities for development, but I don’t know where to.’
With the support of our programme, Tanveer is now on his way to becoming an engineer.
Every year, tens of thousands of secondary school students graduate, but most of them cannot further their studies and instead need to work. With the few skills and little experience they have though, it’s not easy for even a Chinese-speaking graduate to find a job with a promising future, let alone an ethnic minority secondary school graduate.
‘I want to find a job that has good promotion prospects and opportunities for development, but I don’t know where to find a job like that,’ Tanveer, a 20-year-old Pakistani secondary school graduate, said in fluent Cantonese. He, who used to work as a part-time baggage handler at the airport, wants to find a better job. Through the support of Oxfam’s partner, the Catholic Diocese of Hong Kong – Diocesan Pastoral Centre for Workers (Kowloon), a social worker asked Tanveer about his skills and expectations, and found him an elevator mechanic apprenticeship interview. With little knowledge about the industry and a low salary on offer, Tanveer was slightly hesitant at first. After learning that completing the four year programme meant that he could obtain the qualification he needed to become a registered lift worker, and eventually an engineer, he was greatly motivated to apply.
Together with the social worker, Tanveer went for two rounds of interviews and was ultimately given an offer. The in-depth career counselling services the Centre offers ethnic minorities has yielded much better results than that of the Labour Department. Aside from accompanying candidates to job interviews, social workers at the Centre also meet with candidates’ parents to help them better understand their children’s aspirations and career choices, and encourage them to support and respect their children. The aim of the Centre’s career counselling services isn’t just to get job seekers hired though, but to develop their job search skills, expand their horizons and secure jobs that offer better working conditions and prospects.
On the day Tanveer signed his contract, the social worker who accompanied him went through the contract with Tanveer’s father. Tanveer said, ‘I really hope to have my family’s support over these next four years!’
"Do you read me" Photo Exhibition
A photo exhibition on how ethnic minorities learn Chinese’ was jointly organised by Oxfam and photojournalist Ducky Tse in 2014 to raise the awareness about the challenges ethnic minorities face when learning Chinese.
*Report in Chinese only